The Scientifically Perfect Thanksgiving Plate

November 2024

Disclaimer: This is an entirely hypothetical situation, do not take this as a step by step guide on how to enjoy your thanksgiving meal (unless you are a super crazy bodybuilder).There are many valid ways to enjoy Thanksgiving that should be celebrated and appreciated.

Turkey Day is upon us! In just a few weeks families will be gathering around a spread of festive, culturally significant, and of course, delicious foods. Many will aim to create the perfect plate- with just enough of everything they want; they aspire to fill their canvas to the brim with Thanksgiving goodness! However it is hard to gauge exactly what the perfect spread actually IS. Some will load their plates up with every dish, hoping to get everything, and will  eventually run out of room on their plates and in their stomachs. Others may focus on one major food group - for example, heaping loads of potatoes and other carbs onto their plates - losing the opportunity to enjoy variety and nutritional value on their Thanksgiving plate. In this article, I aim to find the most effective Thanksgiving plate when it comes to variables such as taste, variety, nutritional value, and aesthetics

In order to begin, we must first find the most optimal dishes to include in a Thanksgiving spread. According to MyPlate - a project funded by the United States Department of Agriculture - one’s meal should include fruits and vegetables, protein foods, carbohydrates, grains, and dairy. These major food groups serve as the instruction manual for your plate. Yes, some foods definitely check all of the boxes, but others are better nutritionally and more flavorful. With some research, I have identified the most optimal Thanksgiving dishes, listed below for your convenience:

  • Turkey- A fantastic source of lean protein that is low in fat and high in flavor. Also provides other nutrients such as zinc and B vitamins.

  • Ham- Can be a substitution for turkey, is a versatile source of good protein that can shake up your Thanksgiving.

  • Stuffing(whole grain)- Offers fiber, carbs, and other important vitamins and minerals which contributes to digestive health.

  • Mashed Potatoes- Not only are mashed potatoes a fantastic source of carbs, if the skins are left on they can be a great source of fiber.

  • Sweet Potatoes- Sweet potatoes are both a deliciously sweet dish and rich in vitamins A and C.

  • Brussels Sprouts- Flavorful when roasted, high in fiber and vitamins C and K, and rich in antioxidants.

  • Green Bean Casserole- Rich in fiber and antioxidants as well as low in calories, making it a great side dish.

  • Mac n’ Cheese- An addition of dairy and cheesy goodness which offers protein and calcium as well as other nutrients.

  • Cranberry Sauce- Cranberries are practically stuffed with antioxidants as well as vitamins C and E.

  • Gravy- A flavor enhancer that offers healthy fats, proteins, and B vitamins. Along with this, gravy adds moisture to drier dishes.

  • Pumpkin Pie- Ending with a bang! The holiday classic, it’s low in calories and high in important nutrients, fiber, and potassium.

  • Apple Pie- A second option of pie (if you're up for it!) that offers added fiber, vitamins, and flavor

Great! Now we know what foods to eat and their benefits. Now we need to find exactly how much of our plate each of these foods should take up. Let's start with turkey-- the star of the show! Lean protein is important for muscle growth, brain function, and lowered cholesterol. Therefore, it should take up the most space on your plate at 20%. Turkey can also be substituted for ham that has similar benefits with the added bonus of immune system support.

On to the side dishes! Firstly, stuffing-- a delicious side that offers a great source of fiber and carbs. However it should be eaten in moderation so keep it at around 15% of your plate. Next is mashed potatoes, A fan favorite. Yet again, they are a great source of fiber and carbs - but remember, moderation is key. Keep them at around 10% of your plate to enjoy their benefits without risking a spike in your blood sugar. As for sweet potatoes, they are a nice sweet addition to a majority savory plate. This allows for variation in flavor that is so important in any meal, however because of the sugar content in a sweet potato dish it should be kept at around 5% of your plate. Next is brussels sprouts - though they can be substituted by any other vegetable. These not only offer health benefits, but also aesthetic value. Because vegetables add color, they should take up about 5% of your plate. Green bean casserole is great for antioxidants and fiber, however because of the additional toppings on this side dish it should take up 5% of the plate. Because mac n’ cheese is one of the few dishes including dairy and cheese, it should take up approximately 10% in order to balance out both the food groups included on this plate and texture and flavor. Additionally, cranberry sauce is a great source of vitamins, sweet flavor, and color. Just a dollop will provide a great tangy contrast in flavor, it should take up approximately 5% of your plate. Gravy is meant to be drizzled over your mashed potatoes, stuffing, and turkey (if that is your choice of protein). It is a great flavor enhancer that doesn’t overwhelm the meal, when drizzled over other dishes it should take up around 5% of the plate. And finally… of course! Pumpkin pie! One slice should suffice, taking up about 10% of your plate (but maybe put it on a different plate if you don't want courses to touch). But make sure to save me a slice for giving you this advice ;). If you are interested in a second slice of pie, I would recommend apple pie as it is an added source of fiber and vitamins that yet again offers variation in flavor. This ratio not only offers a great variation in flavor, aesthetics, and texture, but also is beneficial nutritionally with just enough of each of the major food groups and a surplus in vitamins, minerals, and other nutrients!

“Okay, that's all well and good, but in what order do we eat these dishes to conserve space in our bellies?” I’m so glad you asked, dear reader! While I can’t necessarily give you an exact scientific order, I can give you some pointers. First, do NOT eat mashed potatoes, stuffing, or sweet potatoes first - EVER - if you want to conserve space in your stomachs. In order to understand why, let me explain ghrelin and leptin. Ghrelin and leptin are hormones that control your appetite and your fullness: ghrelin increases appetite, while leptin signals that you are starting to feel full. When one eats meals that are high in carbohydrates, their leptin levels increase dramatically and make you feel more full. This means eating carb heavy dishes like mashed potatoes, stuffing, and sweet potatoes first will leave you with no space left before you are even halfway through your meal! Instead opt to eat your veggies first; finish the brussels sprouts before anything else. This leaves ample space in your stomach for more food. After you have already eaten something lighter, you can begin to work away at the more carb heavy dishes, but instead of finishing them one by one, try to alternate between each of the dishes along with the cranberry sauce and your choice of protein. This strategy will not only allow you to enjoy all of the flavors in the meal, but will also help you to feel more fulfilled. And to end the meal, save the best for last: dessert. Pie is the perfect way to end your dinner. Ending with a rich, sweet, and creamy pumpkin pie will cleanse your palette, while apple pie is an acidic and flavorful dessert that will create some excitement in your meal. This provides one last hurrah for your Thanksgiving dinner!

I hope everyone has a fantastic Thanksgiving break and Thanksgiving dinner! Remember to add a variety of foods with different flavors, colors, and nutritional benefits to your plate, use the proportions guide to give your plate the perfect ratio, and keep your ghrelin levels high and leptin levels low by starting light then going to the more fulfilling dishes. Thank you for reading my first article as a writer for The Nighthawk Times! It has been such a fun experience to research for and write this article and I can’t wait to write my next one.

Northfield High School’s student-led newspaper. Covering news in and out of the nest.

Find us on Instagram @thenighthawktimes or reach out to us via email.

Photo credits: Pixabay

Email icon

© 2024 The Nighthawk Times

Intuit Mailchimp logo